“Wherever I went I found, as in few other places I have been, just how happy ordinary people were happy to talk. Then I understood that this was because no one ever asks them what they think.”
So writes Tim Judah, a reporter for The Economist, in his compelling book In Wartime: Stories from Ukraine.
The Londoner Judah covered the war in Ukraine for The New York Review of Books.
Judah has a specific approach in his portrayal of the complexities of today’s Ukraine for the Western reader. He stressed that he wanted to mix people, stories, history, politics, and reportage instead of explaining why one event followed another.
In addition to witnessing some horrifying scenes on the front lines of the war in Donbas, he traveled far and wide throughout Ukraine. He talked with people high and low, from impoverished refugees, elderly villagers, city sophisticates, and wealthy businessmen.
One major theme is teased out of all the talks with Ukrainians. History weighs very heavily on Ukraine, Judah writes, “because of what really happened, what people believe happened, what people are told happened, and what is forgotten.”
Furthermore, as Judah notes, what a Ukrainian believes today depends on what he or she believes about the past. And therefore he points out, “People are mobilized, believing horrendously garbled versions of history.”
These versions of history shape contemporary Ukrainian attitudes to the two searing traumas the country experienced in the twentieth century—the Holocaust and the Holodomor Famine.
Judah reminds us history refracts. The same period is remembered differently by different people. Jews, Poles, and Ukrainians have radically different memories and interpretations of events of the Second World War in the western regions of Galicia and Volhynia.
The proper commemoration of these events continues to bedevil Ukrainian society, as Judah shows in his chapters on Lviv, and specifically on the notorious Lonskoho Street Prison. The prison, now a museum, was the site of a bloody massacre of political prisoners by the Soviet secret police in the summer of 1941 just before the German occupation. And in the immediate aftermath of the occupation, it was the site of pogroms.
Judah also notes the oddly truncated historical view of the Famine in Ukrainian commemorations. He shrewdly points out that making the Holodomor a seminal event in modern Ukrainian history has to depend on who is in power.
The Holodomor has been alternately highlighted or neglected by Ukrainian authorities in terms of public remembrance. It was also of course a taboo topic during the Soviet period. Because of factors, Judah points out “the Holodomor has not entered into the DNA or soul of Ukrainian politics, or worldview, as the Holocaust and the Armenian genocide have in Israel and Armenia.”
Judah was covering and writing about Ukraine in a period of traumatic transition. And he reminds us that these traumas often arise suddenly. The long-established order can vanish overnight. Change can be swift, and lethal. Anything could happen anywhere.
In one of his chapters Judah recounts how the American Hassidic Rabbi in Lviv tells him that now there is not a single Jew left in the city whose origins are in Lviv. On Shabbat the rabbi dons his big fur shtreimel hat and walks briskly home from the synagogue. As he hauntingly reminds us, once thousands would have been walking home on a Friday night in their shtreimels.
Way across the country at the eastern end of Ukraine, Judah conjures up the charged atmosphere in Donetsk before the first blood of a new war was shed. This was just before the pro-Russian forces stormed the city. He captures the capacity of the human mind to deny reality. Judah was invited to a Seder, the Passover dinner, of the local Jewish community. As a foreign guest, he was asked to say a few words. He described the roadblocks he saw outside the city. This was all disturbingly similar to what he saw at the beginnings of the Yugoslav wars.
But his audience was not convinced. As he writes, “No one seemed to believe me. No one believed that their world was about to come crashing down. They clapped politely when I said that while the traditional saying of ‘Next year in Jerusalem!’ was fine, ‘Next year in Donetsk.’ would be good too. Few who were present would be.”
In Wartime: Stories From Ukraine by Tim Judah is published by Tim Duggan Books, an imprint of Crown Publishing, and is available from online booksellers.
This has been Ukrainian Jewish Heritage on Nash Holos Ukrainian Roots Radio. From San Francisco, I’m Peter Bejger. Until next time, shalom!
One thought on “Ukrainian Jewish Heritage: Judah in Wartime”
I read ‘In Wartime Stories from Ukraine’ in 2019 and recommend the book.
One entity in particular I noticed mentioned in Twitter tweets is the Azov Battalion. Unlike the vast majority of people that commented about that entity, because of this book that Tim Judah wrote ( Chapter 31, starting with page 172 ), I realize that there’s a sizable amount of grey area with this entity. It’s not black and white. Those categorizing this entity as a flat out neo-nazi organization, which a large number of peple are doing, seems to play right in the hands of the Russian Government.
The book provides perspectives from people on the ground that leads one to see situations in much more depth.
Pawlina, your efforts in leading to the book being promoted on Nash Halos, clearly has helped me see situations in Ukraine in a more everyday / survival mode perspective than if I wasn’t aware of the stories people have gone through in various parts of Ukraine.